Book review: Puppet by Pauline C. Harris

23015970Title: Puppet

Author: Pauline C. Harris

Format/Length: eBook/246 pages

Publisher/Date Published: October 2014/Patchwork Press

Category/Genre: Young Adult/Science Fiction — I think?

Source: Netgalley — Thank you! :)

Goodreads | Author’s Website | Amazon

Description: Penelope lives in a world of advanced technology but many claim society has yet to catch up. Marionettes have advanced in the form of robots; lifelike creations remote controlled to perform super human tasks.

When Penelope makes a deal with Jed, a marionette-obsessed scientist, she doesn’t fully realize what she’s getting herself into. In order for Jed to take her away from the orphanage she lives in, she must first agree to undergo his experiments and tests, ultimately creating something no one ever dreamed possible; the first living marionette.

As Jed shows off his scientific creation to the world, concerns arise surrounding Penelope’s abilities and what she’s capable of doing. Ordered to somehow lessen her abilities, Jed makes a desperate attempt to change Penelope to make her more human, more vulnerable. After Penelope lies to the officials about her past, Jed makes sure it’s the last one she’ll ever utter. The truth is now the only thing she is capable of telling.

As Penelope struggles with her past, her disturbingly new present, and her uncertain future, she is thrust into a magically twisted world of mayhem in search of the one thing she wants, but knows she can never have. The chance to be just a girl again. To be normal. To be real.

 2/5 stars —


Puppet by Pauline C. Harris promised a fantastic concept, but the majority of the novel fell awfully flat. I really wanted to like it, and there were parts of it that I enjoyed, but overall it didn’t reach my expectations. I have to admit that I was definitely curious about this novel from the get go considering the author’s young age. That and I love retellings.

television animated GIF

I’ll start off with something positive: the author’s writing is wonderful. I’d probably read another book of the author’s based on that alone.

The first issue I had with the novel was the limited worldbuilding. I was confused as to what sort of world the author was trying to get across — sci fi? Dystopia? I wish this part of the story had been fleshed out more, so I could actually picture the world. The sci-fi “cell manipulation” talk in the novel seemed rather forced to me, as if the writer didn’t really know what she was talking about and was making it up as she went along. I’m not scientist, so perhaps I can’t judge accurately, but it all seemed very vague and confusing. In order for a science fiction-esque novel to feel real, explanations need to be somewhat understandable to the reader. A lot of it was glazed over, and only explained when absolute necessary — which may not be a bad thing, exactly, but the explanations given felt rather flimsy. If the novel’s world had been explained more, I think it would have been much more enjoyable to read, as well as creating a vivid, intriguing world.

Reaction GIF: disappointed, Neil Patrick Harris, How I Met Your Mother

The characters, too, felt pretty flat, and perhaps this was because the novel itself was very short? I thought the author had more room to elaborate on character motives, especially when it came to the villains of the story. I also wanted to know more about Jed. In saying that though I did enjoy the romance between James and our main character, Pen, and there were some interesting twists and revelations at the end which kept my interest.

Overall, Puppet was an interesting concept. I also enjoyed the “gender-bending” aspect of it all — something I wish I saw more in YA. I wish I could have said I liked this more, but there were just too many elements of the story that I felt needed to be revised before publication.

Reaction GIF: disappointed, sad, Frozen

Have you read Puppet? Let me know! Also — what do you think of retellings? Yea, nay?


10 thoughts on “Book review: Puppet by Pauline C. Harris

  1. So much promise, but sadly it just couldn’t deliver. The cover is kinda creepy. You know who she looks like, remember that girl? She won X Factor I think it was. It’s her, with strings. Finally there’s a use for an NSync GIF as well :D It really could have been so much more, but it sounds like the lack of character development and world building lacked explanation. Even a hundred more pages could have made a huge difference.

    Sorry you didn’t enjoy this one more Kara, but brilliant review poppet <3

  2. Aww, sounds like this could have been a great book if it was tightened up a bit. What a shame because I love retellings as well, and sci-fi is one of my favourite genres. For such a younger author to have come up with a story like this is amazing. I’m sure her next one will be better from the sounds of it! Lovely review Kara xx

  3. Aw that’s just too bad. The cover looks intriguing (and that the author writes well seems like a heads up for me) but if the world building is down then the book just lacks in its wonderful storytelling abilities! Which sucks big time. Thanks for the review, it was very informative!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s